Zoetica Media

  • Home
  • Services
  • Speaking
  • About
  • Resources
  • Blog
  • Contact

The Blame Game: Getting Bloggers and PR Together Without a War

May 14, 2008 by Kami Huyse

Share this:
Twitter0
Facebook0
Google+0
LinkedIn0

close A

I was talking to a good friend on the phone today about the dustup with public relations professionals and Gina Trapani, of Lifehacker, who has launched a PR Spammers blacklist.

Of course, this isn't the first blogger who has been (rightly) disgusted with the overwhelming number of spammy pitches from people hawking their wares.  And even today, Peter Shankman, who recently launched Help A Reporter, is holding a quiz to decide how that community will deal with off topic pitches to the reporters that use it for leads.

We are all looking for ways to reign in our inboxes and regain some semblance of productivity.  If only this blacklisting could accomplish the aim of unclogging my mailbox, I might even join in with a blacklist of my own.

But it doesn't really help.

I can understand the defensive stance by many of the public relations and marking professionals whom I admire and who are in large part tired of being whipping posts for something that isn't entirely their fault. I can't blame them, but the attitude is wrongheaded. I can also appreciate the heartfelt apologies from some of my other colleagues, which again are nice, but that don't solve the problem.

And most likely, nothing ever will.

In the comments of Mack Collier's excellent summary, a commenter reveals that Gina's personal e-mail was on Cision's blogger media list.  And with that, Todd Defren sighed with some relief that maybe his company and weren't completely to blame, while openly admitting that the lists are problematic. Anyone who has used them know this to be true.

But I am concerned that we as public relations professionals have come to rely on these time saving lists too much.  And once the wrong information ends up in these lists, it can exacerbate the problem.  And once your name ends up on these lists, it becomes much too easy to get 1,000s of off topic pitches. As the editor of a B to B publication for seven years, I experienced this first hand.  And also as a blogger, I have had similar experiences.

The lists are not the only problem, there is also the problem of uncreative pitches and blatant one-size-fits-all e-mails.  Kevin Duggan has a whole blog dedicated to that problem.

And the worst offenders will never even read the criticism, much less reform to it.

GeekMommy says something that I think gets closer to the heart of the problem:

As a consumer, I know that you are both part of the chain [PR/Journalists/Bloggers]… but dammit, I want my information. I want to know what those companies want to tell me. I don’t want you guys playing games where you don’t talk to each other – because that’s not your job. Your job is to get that information from the companies to the consumers… because if you guys won’t? Trust me, eventually, somebody else will.”

The Scarlet Letter: Who Is to Blame?

Alas, all of this finger pointing has me turning back to high school literature for a proper analogy and the The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne, where the character Hester bore the blame for a rotten system.

Like the PR person, Hester took the blame (to the death) for an adulterous affair. But were her lover and accusers any less to blame? One as a partner in crime and other as overzealously judgmental – sending her to her death.

But what is the solution?  How do journalists and hapless bloggers get their inbox back without waging an all out war against each other?

I think that a credo of things to do before pitching a blogger is a nice idea, but we did that for astroturfing and there is still plenty of that going on (heck, I even wrote that code of ethics personally).

I like Stowe Boyd's philosophy of MicroPR, probably because it is already the way that I operate, but the truth remains that even the “good guys,” whoever they may be, can get lumped in with the “bad guys” due to the sheer volume of the problem.

What do you think is the solution?

Filed Under: Industry Trends, Influencer Outreach

About Kami Huyse

Kami Watson Huyse, CEO of Zoetica, is passionate about great communication. Working in Public Relations since 1994, and blogging since 2005, she has seen trends come and go, but one thing has stayed the same – people are looking for ways to authentically connect. She loves to connect with readers, so leave a comment or follow @kamichat on Twitter and connect there.

Subscribe to get the newsletter and premiums

Enter your email to subscribe:

  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter

About Zoetica

Zoetica Swish SmallWelcome to Zoetica! We are an experienced team of communicators led by Kami Huyse who are dedicated to teaching you how to bring your communication to life with sound strategy, community building and solid success measures. Check out our blog, Zoetica Talks, browse our Resources, and check out our Sevices.We can't wait to get to know you better.

Recent Posts

  • Which Social Media Platforms to Use for Business in 2023
  • Creative Professionals, Get Ready for the Artificial Intelligence Takeover
  • The 5 Social Media Trends That Will Shape the Industry in 2023
  • The 5-Part Visibility Plan That Will Help Promote and Grow Your Business
  • Are You Ready for AI in Creative Work?

Zoetica in the News

5 Tools to Measure (and Manage) Reputation in Complex Environment PR News Byline

2014 trends for public relations, marketing and social media | Business | Kentucky.com (mobile mention) 

Digital PR & Social Media Guidebook – Contributing Author

How Communicators Can Get Started with PR Measurement, PR News Mention

Proving PR’s Value in the Age of ROI—How to Tie Results to Corporate Objectives | Bulldog Reporter (Speaker)

A Gnawing Crisis in PR: Measuring The ROI on Social Media Channels, PR News Byline

Named as one of AGBeat's top 50 industry influencers in 2014

Will Houston B2B companies answer the social media call? - Houston Business Journal

Social Media Measurement Twitter Chat: Evaluating Impact of Social Media on Foundation Outcomes (with tweets) · RWJF (Moderator)

Top 100 Social Media Power Influencers in Houston 2013

Named as one of 30 PR Experts You Should Follow on Twitter by e-releases

BusinessWire Congrats for Making the Top 100 Women on Twitter

Posts by Topic

Zoetica Talks

 

#SMBHOU

Influencer Outreach

Best Ranked

Measurement

Book Shelf

Nonprofit and CSR

Community

Online Ethics

CoolTools

Social Media Tactics

Crisis

Guidelines

How To

Social Networks

Humor

Speaking

Trends

Strategy

Latest Tweets

Tweets by @kamichat
© Zoetica, LLC | Disclaimer | Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2023 - Zoetica Media · designed/developed by Petersen Media Group