Zoetica Media

  • Home
  • Services
  • Speaking
  • About
  • Resources
  • Blog
  • Contact

Standardized or Custom Blogger Outreach Campaigns? Weighing the Risk

December 16, 2008 by Kami Huyse

Share this:
Twitter0
Facebook0
Google+0
LinkedIn0

If you follow me on Twitter you will see that I interact frequently. I have found and shared a lot of resources there and made and connections that would have taken much longer through just blogging and commenting.

It's a great tool, but it also can fuel controversy.

The Twitter Mob

Over the past few months there have been a number of controversies that have sprung up through Twitter that have led to interesting discussions, but may have been overblown in their black and white knee-jerk reaction.

The format allows anyone to quickly post an opinion that can be virally spread across multiple networks very quickly. The short format doesn't allow for much nuance either.

The most recent dust-up was over Chris Brogan's post on his Dad-o-Matic blog about a shopping spree at K-Mart in which he bought a bunch of gifts to donate to Toys-for-Tots. Chris writes two blogs, his very popular Community and Social Media blog, which is written in his role as a new media consultant with his company New Marketing Labs. He also writes his less popular but respectable blog Dad-o-Matic, on which he writes “views, news, reviews, and advice” about parenting for Dads.

It turns out that Chris serves on the the board of Izea, which arranged for the shopping spree. He was testing a new concept for Izea.

I have to admit that I have strenuously advised my clients away from purchasing Pay-per-Post campaigns. I think that the resulting posts are almost always inauthentic sounding (more like a press release) and I worry that eventually Google will penalize them for it. Izea is headed by Ted Murphy, who behind the original Pay-per-Post and its offspring Social Spark – both of which were very controversial upon their launch.

The popular Forrester analyst and blogger Jeremiah Owyang asked a few questions of Chris about his post, and suddenly Twitter was ablaze with accusations about Chris' credibility. Jeremiah has been clear that he does not question Brogan's credibility, but just wanted to dig into his motivations.

Chris gave his thoughtful response to the criticism, and about the idea of sponsored posts overall.

Why Paid Links Are Ineffective

I have to admit that I have strenuously advised my clients away from purchasing Pay-per-Post campaigns. I think that the resulting posts are almost always inauthentic sounding (more like a press release) and Google has already penalized blogs that carry the links.

The main problem I see with pay-per-post campaigns is the wholesale goal of getting as many links as possible, with quality being little more than an afterthought.

Matt Cutts, a Google engineer and head of its web spam team addresses posts written for pay and how to report them here.

I still really don't like this model.

Why Thoughtful Giveaways are Different

However, a new model has started to arise, which is where a “sponsor” or a company offers the blogger a sample of the product to get their feedback, good or bad. They are also usually offered a similar package to give away to their blog readers in a contest.

Parenting bloggers will be particularly familiar with this model. In the interest of full disclosure, I just won a recent contest through this model as a participant.

As a consultant, I have run a number of campaigns for clients using this model over the past year and a half. It is generally a win-win for all involved. What I have found as we have worked this model is that people like to hear about relevant experiences from bloggers, and they also like the opportunity to have the same experience. It also mitigates that main problem of pay-per-post campaigns since disclosure is required by default.

The giveaway/contest model helps to reduce what I like to call the “envy factor,” which is the backlash to certain bloggers getting special treatment over others.

Consider the Culture

The feeling that the Internet has flattened influence is within the common culture of most bloggers. Even though it is the case that some bloggers are clearly more popular than others, the overall feeling, by even top bloggers, is that anyone can break in. You can see a comment by well-known blogger Robert Scoble on this topic here and another article here.

It is critical to keep this culture in mind when you design outreach campaigns or it can backfire in negativity, especially if the bloggers chosen for the experience are especially high profile.

Standardization Holds Hazards

Clearly Izea sees a profit opportunity in standardizing these types of campaigns and possibly leveraging its already impressive network of top blogs that participate in some of its other programs.

while Izea's standardized method of outreach is tantalizing for companies looking for a way to approach social media, I feel it carries a number of hazards.

Often before embarking on any such program I have reached out to bloggers in that segment to ask their advice before stepping out of the gate. I am not sure Izea's model really allows for that level of standardization, but I will be interested to see.

The most important consideration is that outreach must be tailored to fit the segment. What is permissible in the parenting segment would be sacrilegious in the Technology side. Public relations, marketing and social media bloggers are very sensitive to authentic communication and will raise an outcry, as was the case with Chris Brogan's post. Add the mixing pot of Twitter to the fray, where all these segments can mingle, and you can get a potent cocktail.

I applaud Chris for wading in so publicly to demonstrate this with his own blog properties, I certainly have had a lot of my thoughts reinforced about how to approach such experiments for clients. I consider Chris Brogan a colleague and friend and realize that he took some major risks here.

I would love to hear your thoughts. If you are a company have tried the Giveaway campaign or if you are a blogger have you participated? Why or why not?

Credit: I found the photo of the custom-made glove used to illustrate this post on Flickr. It was made by Bug Eater's Knit Knack Shack on Etsy. This was NOT a sponsored post but I thought it was a good analogy.

Filed Under: Crisis Communication Tagged With: social media

About Kami Huyse

Kami Watson Huyse, CEO of Zoetica, is passionate about great communication. Working in Public Relations since 1994, and blogging since 2005, she has seen trends come and go, but one thing has stayed the same – people are looking for ways to authentically connect. She loves to connect with readers, so leave a comment or follow @kamichat on Twitter and connect there.

Subscribe to get the newsletter and premiums

Enter your email to subscribe:

  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter

About Zoetica

Zoetica Swish SmallWelcome to Zoetica! We are an experienced team of communicators led by Kami Huyse who are dedicated to teaching you how to bring your communication to life with sound strategy, community building and solid success measures. Check out our blog, Zoetica Talks, browse our Resources, and check out our Sevices.We can't wait to get to know you better.

Recent Posts

  • Which Social Media Platforms to Use for Business in 2023
  • Creative Professionals, Get Ready for the Artificial Intelligence Takeover
  • The 5 Social Media Trends That Will Shape the Industry in 2023
  • The 5-Part Visibility Plan That Will Help Promote and Grow Your Business
  • Are You Ready for AI in Creative Work?

Zoetica in the News

5 Tools to Measure (and Manage) Reputation in Complex Environment PR News Byline

2014 trends for public relations, marketing and social media | Business | Kentucky.com (mobile mention) 

Digital PR & Social Media Guidebook – Contributing Author

How Communicators Can Get Started with PR Measurement, PR News Mention

Proving PR’s Value in the Age of ROI—How to Tie Results to Corporate Objectives | Bulldog Reporter (Speaker)

A Gnawing Crisis in PR: Measuring The ROI on Social Media Channels, PR News Byline

Named as one of AGBeat's top 50 industry influencers in 2014

Will Houston B2B companies answer the social media call? - Houston Business Journal

Social Media Measurement Twitter Chat: Evaluating Impact of Social Media on Foundation Outcomes (with tweets) · RWJF (Moderator)

Top 100 Social Media Power Influencers in Houston 2013

Named as one of 30 PR Experts You Should Follow on Twitter by e-releases

BusinessWire Congrats for Making the Top 100 Women on Twitter

Posts by Topic

Zoetica Talks

 

#SMBHOU

Influencer Outreach

Best Ranked

Measurement

Book Shelf

Nonprofit and CSR

Community

Online Ethics

CoolTools

Social Media Tactics

Crisis

Guidelines

How To

Social Networks

Humor

Speaking

Trends

Strategy

Latest Tweets

Tweets by @kamichat
© Zoetica, LLC | Disclaimer | Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2023 - Zoetica Media · designed/developed by Petersen Media Group